logo
logo
Sign in

Asphalt Roofing Shingles: Traditional Shingles vs. Shake-Style

avatar
Carolyn Lynch
Asphalt Roofing Shingles: Traditional Shingles vs. Shake-Style

Most homeowners pay little attention to their roofing Shingles. But, when it comes to replacing their roofs, choosing the right shingles is very essential. With that in mind, our experts have prepared this handy guide to help you know the main difference between traditional and modern shake-style shingles so that you can make a well-informed decision. Let’s get started.

Traditional shingles:

  • Roofing Layers: Traditional shingles have only one layer of roofing material. They are usually plain and dimensionless. So, there's minimal 3D or shadowing effect. These shingles come with different levels of durability and weight.
  • Longevity: Their high-quality fiberglass basemat is designed to provide reliability and flexibility at an affordable price. These shingles have a lifespan of between 20- and 30-years. Depending on the manufacturer, most of these shingles come with a warranty of 20 to 25 years. Traditional asphalt shingles including 3-Tab come with a UL Class A fire-resistance rating. However, they're not as resistant to the wind as shake-style shingles.
  • Cost: Traditional 3-Tab shingles are still the most affordable option when it comes to roof replacement. Their low cost, without compromising on the durability, is the reason why they're still popular among homeowners. Secondly, the majority of the existing roofs in the US are built with 3-Tab shingles. So, they need the same types of shingles for repairs.


Shake-Style Shingles:

  • Roofing Layers: These Shingles are stronger and bigger. They are also made of asphalt, but they're composed of several layers for enhanced durability and strength. High-quality shake-style shingles from trusted brands like CertainTeed come in triple-laminate options and are made of multiple layers of an extra durable fiberglass base. So, if you're looking for the thickest and the toughest shingles for your roof, go for shake-style luxury shingles.
  • Performance & Durability: With their triple laminate construction, shake style shingles are some of the most durable and high-performance shingles out there. Their triple-layer construction makes them highly resistant to heavy winds and powerful storms. They're a great choice for roofs that are constantly exposed to severe weather conditions. These shingles can easily withstand wind speeds of up to 100 miles an hour.
  • Cost: These shingles are a bit more expensive than the 3 Tab shingles. However, they can instantly boost the durability and aesthetics of your roof. And it’s a well-known fact that your roof accounts for nearly 50 to 60% of your home's curb appeal.

You can save some money upfront by opting for traditional Three-tab shingles, but you can't expect them to give your home a premium look. And you'll get an extended warranty with 3-Tab shingles. Since the lifespan of shake-style shingles can be twice that of regular 3-Tab shingles, provided you maintain them properly, you can save substantial money in the long run.

Looking For a New Roof?

Get in touch with roofing contractors Jackson MS at 601-299-4048 or fill out our online form to schedule a free, in-home consultation today.

collect
0
avatar
Carolyn Lynch
guide
Zupyak is the world’s largest content marketing community, with over 400 000 members and 3 million articles. Explore and get your content discovered.
Read more