Evolution of Procurement Outsourcing
Procurement outsourcing has evolved significantly over the past few decades. In the early days, most companies only outsourced non-core activities like maintenance, repair and operations (MRO) procurement to third-party providers. However, as procure-to-pay processes became more complex with expanding supply chains and global trade, more companies started outsourcing strategic sourcing and supplier relationship management activities.
By the late 1990s and early 2000s, many organizations had established large centralized procurement departments to manage spend across all categories. This led to the emergence of professional procurement outsourcing (PPO) firms that could replicate the functions of an in-house procurement unit. PPO allowed companies to essentially "rent" an entire procurement department for a fixed annual fee.
Presently, we see procurement business process outsourcing (PBPO) where third parties manage end-to-end procure-to-pay processes using a shared services model. With advancements in technologies like artificial intelligence (AI) and cloud computing, the scope of PBPO is expanding to include advanced analytics-driven supply chain planning as well.
Key Benefits of Procurement Outsourcing
Cost savings through scale and specialization: Procurement outsourcing providers achieve economies of scale by serving multiple clients simultaneously. Their specialist teams are also more productive in procure-to-pay activities compared to internal generalists.
Access to talent and best practices: Procurers at third parties stay up to date with industry innovations and continuously enhance their sourcing strategies. Companies can leverage their expertise without having to hire and retain high-caliber recruitment professionals.
Capital and operational expenditure avoidance: Outsourcing eliminates the need for capital investment in procurement infrastructure and resources. It converts fixed operational costs to a variable pay-as-you-go model through annual subscription fees.
Risk mitigation: Vendors handle supplier disputes, changes in trade policies etc. allowing clients to focus on core operations. Strong vendor governance also ensures compliance.
Flexibility and faster ROI: Scale and talent can be accessed instantly without long recruitment cycles. Variable subscription models provide flexibility to scale operations up or down as business needs change.
Key Challenges of Procurement Outsourcing
Loss of control and visibility: While vendors are accountable, clients have lesser control over day-to-day operations and source of cost-savings. Detailed reporting is required to retain visibility.
Cultural integration issues: Building aligned goals and working styles between the outsourcer and client requires time and effort from both sides. Differences may arise due to dissimilar incentive structures.
Transition and ramp-up difficulties: Setting up outsourced procurement and migrating existing processes involves significant upfront investments and paperwork. Ramps up can take 6-12 months to stabilize.
Lack of strategic insight: Tactical procure-to-pay roles may get outsourced but overall strategic sourcing planning is something most companies prefer to retain internally.
Vendor dependence and switching costs: Clients become overly reliant on fewer qualified providers. Substantial retention incentives and high switching costs make many hesitant to change vendors mid-contract.
Data security and business continuity risks: Regulatory compliances, cyber threats and ensuring uninterrupted operations even during vendor transition or failures require careful contracts and oversight.
Benefits Realization of Procurement Outsourcing
For procurement outsourcing to truly deliver promised benefits, strategic planning and diligent management post-engagement are vital. Specifically:
- Define granular objectives and key performance indicators (KPIs) to evaluate success and ensure contractual alignment.
- Retain a small in-house procurement center of excellence team for oversight, reporting and new initiative approvals.
- Implement robust governance frameworks for audit rights, escalation protocols in case of performance issues and periodic business reviews.
- Carefully plan the transition to outsource minimal disruption. Conduct mock drills and establish a structured knowledge-transfer program.
- Continuously enhance contracts based on evolving needs through open communication and cooperation between parties.
- Consider co-sourcing or a shared services model for control and customization balance rather than full outsourcing in some cases.
With the above enablers, procurement outsourcing continues to be an effective strategy for many organizations to leverage external expertise and maximize value from their supplier networks in a cost-efficient way. Both clients and service providers must work diligently to overcome initial challenges and ensure true strategic partnership over the long-term.
Get more insights on This Topic- Procurement Outsourcing
